The same alleged conduct may lead to both a domestic violence restraining-order proceeding and a criminal investigation or prosecution. This creates difficult decisions because statements made in the civil DVRO case may affect the criminal matter, while the DVRO hearing may still proceed.
The Right Against Self-Incrimination May Be Involved
A respondent facing a related criminal case may choose to invoke the constitutional privilege against self-incrimination rather than testify about events that could affect the criminal matter.
Whether and how to invoke that privilege requires careful analysis. A respondent should not assume that filing a detailed written response or testifying in the DVRO case has no effect outside family court.
A Criminal Case Does Not Automatically Delay the DVRO
A pending criminal case does not provide an automatic right to postpone all related civil proceedings. The family court generally has discretion to grant or deny a requested continuance.
The court may weigh the respondent’s constitutional concerns against the protected person’s need for timely civil relief. The result depends on the specific circumstances and the court’s findings.
The Respondent May Still Present a Defense
A respondent who does not testify may still challenge the request by cross-examining the petitioner and other witnesses, making legal arguments, presenting appropriate documents, and calling other witnesses.
Those alternatives do not guarantee that the DVRO will be denied. The judge evaluates the admissible evidence and decides whether the requested protection is supported.
Existing Protective Orders Remain Binding
Invoking the privilege, requesting a continuance, or defending a criminal charge does not suspend an existing temporary restraining order. Every current no-contact, stay-away, custody, property, firearm, and related provision must continue to be followed unless the court changes it.
Coordination between family-law and criminal-defense counsel may be important because decisions in one proceeding can affect the other.
A California DVRO attorney can work with criminal-defense counsel, evaluate whether a response or testimony is appropriate, and present a defense without treating a related criminal case as an automatic pause of the protective-order proceeding.

Comments are closed