A lawyer may privately retain an accountant, appraiser, or other specialist to evaluate a divorce issue before deciding whether the expert should testify. Communications with a true consulting expert may be protected, but that protection can be lost through the way the expert is retained or used.

A Consultant Helps Evaluate the Case Privately

A consulting expert may help counsel understand the strengths and weaknesses of a property, income, reimbursement, or valuation claim. Communications among the attorney, client, and properly retained consultant are generally protected.

This allows candid analysis before deciding whether expert testimony is necessary. Merely calling someone a consultant, however, does not protect unrelated information that was already discoverable.

The Attorney Should Make the Retention

The source materials distinguish an expert retained by counsel from an expert hired independently by the client. An attorney-retained consultant may function as the lawyer’s agent for purposes of confidential case analysis.

A client generally cannot transform an expert’s earlier independent work into protected attorney work simply by later giving it to counsel.

Using the Expert as a Witness Changes the Analysis

Once the consultant is designated to testify or the expert’s opinion is introduced into evidence, confidentiality protections are generally lost. The expert may become subject to discovery concerning opinions, communications, notes, and materials reviewed.

Submitting the expert’s declaration can have the same effect. The decision to convert a consultant into a trial witness should therefore be made deliberately.

Even Identifying the Consultant Can Create Risk

Revealing the consultant’s identity in an application for expert fees may support an argument that protection regarding the consultant’s opinions was waived. Direct payment records or client communications can also disclose the relationship.

The retention agreement, payment process, court filings, and communications should be structured carefully. Confidentiality should never be assumed after information has been disclosed.

A California divorce attorney can retain a consultant in the proper capacity, protect confidential analysis, and evaluate whether the benefit of presenting expert testimony outweighs the discovery consequences.

Tags:

No responses yet

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Comments

No comments to show.